Subscribe      List an Event or Business      Invite a Writer      Write for WN      Writers      Other Locations

Jamie's Italian - York

Home > Leeds > Restaurants | Food and Wine
by Katie Thompson (subscribe)
University of York Graduate, aspiring to be a journalist with dreams of one day publishing my own novel. Blog: Published work can be seen at and
Published September 28th 2012

Gordon Ramsay operates by the adage, 'people will wait for good food.' Jamie Oliver, on the other hand, still needs to find the balance between good food and good service.

Presumably the relative busyness of Jamie's Italian on a Wednesday night can be attributed to the 'that-bloke-off-the-telly' novelty value. The eatery portrayed a youthful theme which was consistent throughout the evening; upon arrival, three nervous members of waiting staff, whose combined age could not have surpassed my own, tried tirelessly to seat us, but did not take our order for another fifteen minutes. That said, when they did finally approach us, their attentiveness could not have been faulted, and the modern décor and lively atmosphere seemed to pass the time.

Despite the rather purse-purging prices, I decided to sample a bit of everything to make a fair judgement, and thus opted for a rather phallic-looking courgette fritto as a starter. Despite appearances, the mozzarella kicked in at just the right moment and complemented the pesto dressing perfectly.

To keep a modest budget I opted for a starter-sized main, which, at £8.95, caused me to have high expectations. What ensued however was a laughably small portion of seaside risotto which, while delicious, certainly did not merit the hefty price tag. The juice was certainly not worth the squeeze with regard to pulling apart the mussels and cockles, and the dish was arguably too heavy on the chilli, although I was assured by the waitress that said spice was typical of Jamie's cooking style.

Two courses in and slightly squiffy on a £26.95 bottle of Verdicchio, (which was not dissimilar to a £3.99 bottle I've been known the purchase from the corner shop) it was time for dessert. Rather unadventurously I decided to try out Jamie's take on a chocolate brownie, which, according to his recipe, should have had a gooey centre, but was let down but a rather dry consistency, albeit somewhat salvaged by the sinfully delectable vanilla ice cream.

All in all, Mr Oliver gets a gold star for atmosphere - presenting a board of antipasti on top of two tins of tomatoes was just one of the many gimmicks. That said, one does have high expectations with such a pricey menu, and this time round, Jamie's Italian did not quite hit the mark. I'm a great believer in second chances however, and put the evening's few hiccups (mainly nervous staff) down to the teething problems of any new restaurant, as Jamie's opened officially in July. Suffice to say, I would go again, but perhaps this time round, I'll sacrifice the wine for a decent-sized main.
Help us improve  Click here if you liked this article  19
Share: email  facebook  twitter
Why? To sample some authentic Italian cooking
Phone: 01904 238 979
Where: 26 Lendal, York, YO1 8AA
Your Comment
Great article Katie, congratulations.
by Shannon Meyerkort (score: 3|1828) 3600 days ago
Articles from other cities
by Wendy on 07/07/2012
by Alli-jayne on 10/09/2012
by Simone Ribeiro on 21/09/2012
by Olivia Monaghan on 01/10/2011
by Sarah Han on 26/10/2011
by Yvet Jones on 01/08/2013
Popular Articles